Struggle, teaching, and the children's books, 1954–1970
Between 1954 and 1956 Lawrence painted Struggle: From the History of the American People, thirty panels covering the years 1775 to 1817. He had planned sixty and stopped halfway. Instead of giving the panels titles he labeled each one with a quotation, and the choices are pointed.[10]
For the panel on Patrick Henry he took a less familiar line from the same speech: "Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery." A panel showing a slave revolt carries the words of a man who sued for his freedom in 1773: "We have no property! We have no wives! No children! We have no city! No country!" The series also reaches subjects rarely painted, among them Margaret Cochran Corbin in combat and the wall built by enslaved workers that protected the American position at the Battle of New Orleans.
No museum bought the series in the political climate of the mid-1950s. The panels went instead to a private collector, who sold them on one by one. Three of them, panels 14, 20 and 29, have never been found, and three others were traced in 2017, 2020 and 2021. The Peabody Essex Museum in Salem, Massachusetts, gathered the surviving panels for an exhibition that opened in January 2020 and traveled to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Birmingham Museum of Art, the Seattle Art Museum and the Phillips Collection.[11]
The Brooklyn Museum of Art mounted a retrospective in 1960. Lawrence taught at the New School for Social Research, the Art Students League, Pratt Institute and the Skowhegan School during these years. In 1969 he was one of about two hundred Black artists in a show sponsored by the Philadelphia School District and the Pennsylvania Civic Center Museum.[12]
He also worked for children. Harriet and the Promised Land, published in 1968, used the paintings from his Harriet Tubman series, and The New York Times listed it among the year's best illustrated books. Two more volumes followed, drawn from the John Brown and Migration series. In 1970 he illustrated eighteen of Aesop's Fables for Windmill Press, and the University of Washington Press published his full set of twenty-three in 1998.
Reception and changing reputation
Recognition came early, and from inside Harlem first. Charles Alston wrote in 1938 that Lawrence had escaped both academic training and current fashion, and praised the color he got out of flat tempera. The Migration Series made him nationally known at twenty-three, and within a year Fortune, the Downtown Gallery and two major museums had all taken it up.
Reviewing a further set of thirty Harlem paintings in The New York Times in 1943, Howard Devree called the group "an amazing social document" and wrote that Lawrence had grown "in his use of rhythm as well as in sheer design and fluency." Devree also noted a strong semi-abstract approach and color he judged fitting for the subjects.
The path was not straight. Struggle found no museum buyer in the mid-1950s, was sold to a private collector and broken up panel by panel, and three of its thirty paintings are still missing. Honours accumulated later. The NAACP awarded him the Spingarn Medal in 1970. He was elected to the National Academy of Design in 1978 and to the American Academy of Arts and Letters in 1983, and received the National Medal of Arts in 1990. Eighteen institutions gave him honorary degrees, among them Harvard, Yale, Howard, Amherst and New York University.
A retrospective planned before his death opened at the Phillips Collection in May 2001 and traveled to the Whitney Museum of American Art, the Los Angeles County Museum of Art and the Museum of Fine Arts, Houston. A catalogue raisonné of the paintings, drawings and murals appeared the same year. His last public commission, a mosaic in Murano glass called New York in Transit, was installed in the Times Square subway station in October 2001.
The market followed. The White House Historical Association bought The Builders, painted in 1947, for $2.5 million at auction in May 2007, and the picture has hung in the Green Room of the White House since 2009. In 2018 The Businessmen sold for $6.1 million. His obituary in The New York Times called him "one of America's leading modern figurative painters" and "among the most impassioned visual chroniclers of the African-American experience."