Regeneration
Both examine shell shock and the pressure to return soldiers to military usefulness.
Read our take
The Return of the Soldier
by Rebecca West
A soldier comes home without fifteen years of memory, forcing three women to decide what a cure would restore—and destroy.
- 1918
- 208
- Melancholy
- Elegiac
- Atmospheric
- lyrical
- intimate
- voice-driven
The story, briefly
Spoiler-freeDuring the First World War, Captain Chris Baldry returns to his wealthy English home with no memory of the previous fifteen years. He does not recognize his wife Kitty and believes he is still in love with Margaret Allington, the innkeeper's daughter he knew before either of them married. Chris's cousin Jenny narrates as the household asks whether restoring his memory is necessarily the same as helping him.
The story, in more detail
Jenny and Kitty have spent the war preserving Baldry Court as a beautiful refuge for Chris. His amnesia exposes how little the polished house matches the life he most wants to remember. He recognizes Jenny only as the young cousin of his remembered world and experiences Kitty as a stranger.[1]
Margaret is now Mrs Grey and lives with far less money. Kitty and Jenny initially judge her clothes, address, and speech before they accept that she knows Chris's inner life better than they do. Her presence calms him because he believes their youthful relationship at Monkey Island is still current.[1]
Dr Anderson believes the missing years may be a defense against an adult life Chris cannot bear. A memory strong enough to reconnect those years could restore him, but it would also return grief, an unhappy marriage, and military duty. The women must decide what they owe him when happiness and adult truth point in different directions.[1]
The full plot
Jenny and Kitty wait at Baldry Court for news of Chris. Margaret Grey, an unfamiliar working-class visitor, arrives with a telegram saying Chris is wounded and has contacted her. Kitty assumes the woman is attempting a fraud.[1]
A letter from Chris's clergyman cousin Frank confirms that Chris is recovering in a Boulogne hospital but has lost fifteen years of memory. He believes it is 1901, thinks he is unmarried, and calls for Margaret Allington.[1]
Chris returns home. He recognizes Jenny only as the younger cousin he remembers and treats Kitty as a stranger. Baldry Court looks altered and oppressive to him rather than comforting.[1]
Jenny visits Margaret's modest home and learns that she and Chris fell in love at Monkey Island. A quarrel and failed letters separated them. Margaret married William Grey; Chris built the life he can no longer remember.[1]
Margaret visits Baldry Court. Chris immediately recognizes her, and their renewed closeness makes him peaceful. Jenny's class contempt begins to change as she sees Margaret's generosity and emotional intelligence.[1]
Kitty tries doctors and reminders from their married life. None restores Chris's memory. Dr Anderson explains that amnesia may protect him from a life with which his deeper self is dissatisfied. He believes a sufficiently powerful memory could reconnect the missing years.[1]
Margaret notices a photograph of Oliver, Chris and Kitty's son, who died at two. She connects Oliver to her own dead son Dick and understands that the child's belongings can break through Chris's amnesia.[1]
Margaret initially refuses because restoring Chris will destroy his happiness and may return him to the trenches. Jenny agrees briefly, then concludes that leaving him permanently inside a protected past would also deny his adult dignity.[1]
How it ends — spoilers ahead
Margaret carries Oliver's blue jersey and red ball into the garden. West does not show her conversation with Chris. Jenny and Kitty remain inside, which keeps the decisive act with Margaret while denying the household a comforting scene of treatment.
When Chris crosses the lawn afterward, his youthful looseness is gone. The grief of Oliver's death, the marriage he forgot, and the war all return with his memory. His body again carries the hard bearing of a soldier.
Kitty sees the familiar gait and says that he is cured. Jenny knows the same cure restores suffering and military duty. The novel's last description—Chris as every inch a soldier—turns medical recovery into another form of loss.
Themes and analysis
Memory as refuge and prison
Chris's lost years remove the trenches, Oliver's death, and an emotionally empty marriage. The amnesia gives him genuine relief. It also makes him dependent on other people's management and unable to choose a future informed by what happened.
The novel does not say that truth automatically feels better. It asks whether dignity requires access to a painful life and whether love can justify protecting someone from the history that formed him.
Class decides who looks credible
Kitty and Jenny first read Margaret's address, clothes, boots, and speech as evidence against her. Her knowledge repeatedly proves more accurate than the household's money or social confidence.
Jenny's changing description of Margaret is one of the book's moral movements. Margaret does not become more worthy when Jenny notices her worth; the narrator becomes less limited.
The women perform the work of homecoming
Chris's condition becomes a decision made largely among Jenny, Kitty, and Margaret. They interpret symptoms, manage the house, test memories, and finally choose whether the treatment should be used.
Margaret bears the hardest part. She must use the memory that destroys both Chris's happiness and her own place beside him. The novel makes domestic moral labor part of war's cost.
Why the word cured hurts
Kitty uses cured to mean that the familiar husband has returned. Jenny sees that the same recovery restores grief and the possibility of being sent back to war. Treatment succeeds medically without becoming an uncomplicated victory.
Writing style
West uses Jenny's first-person account. Jenny is deeply involved but cannot see the household clearly at first. Her descriptions of Kitty's beauty and Margaret's clothes are elaborate and class-conscious; as she learns what Margaret means to Chris, her language and judgments change.
The prose is more figurative than the novel's short length might suggest. Rooms, gardens, faces, clothes, and light become ways to describe social and emotional conditions. Baldry Court begins as protected green pleasantness and ends as the place Chris approaches with dread.
Most combat stays offstage. Jenny's nightmares, a hospital letter, Chris's posture, and the final sentence bring the trenches into the country house. West concentrates on what war does to memory and relationships rather than narrating the front directly.
The 1982 film
Alan Bridges directed the 1982 adaptation with Glenda Jackson, Julie Christie, Ann-Margret, and Alan Bates. The screen version necessarily shows faces and encounters that Jenny's prose filters through judgment; the novel's moral pressure still depends on who is allowed to interpret Chris.
Why we recommend it
War shown through home
The trenches remain mostly offstage, but their effects govern every room and relationship.
A narrator capable of changing
Jenny's class prejudice is visible, and the novel makes her revision part of the story.
A devastating final word
The successful cure restores the adult life and suffering that amnesia had removed.
What this book explores
The people in its pages
Jenny Baldry
Chris's cousin and first-person narrator, whose judgments change as the crisis unfolds.
Captain Chris Baldry
A First World War officer who returns home with fifteen years missing from his memory.
Kitty Baldry
Chris's wife, whom he cannot remember, and the guardian of the polished life he no longer recognizes.
Margaret Grey
Chris's former love and the one person his damaged memory recognizes emotionally.
Also in the book
Dr Anderson
The doctor who treats Chris's amnesia as a defense rather than a simple missing file.
Frank Baldry
Chris's clergyman cousin, whose hospital letter confirms the startling diagnosis.
William Grey
Margaret's husband, whose modest household belongs to the adult life Chris does not remember.
Bring it to book club
- Why does methodical restoration of memory count as treatment if it makes Chris less happy?
- How does Jenny's description of Margaret change, and what does that reveal about Jenny?
- What has Kitty built at Baldry Court for Chris, and why does he experience it as oppressive?
- Why does Margaret initially refuse to use Oliver's belongings?
- Does the decision to cure Chris respect his dignity or sacrifice him to social expectations?
- Why does West keep the final conversation between Margaret and Chris offstage?
- What does the last description of Chris as a soldier change about the meaning of recovery?
Timeline
1918
The Return of the Soldier is published during the First World War.
1928
John van Druten's stage adaptation, The Return of the Soldier, opens.
1982
Alan Bridges directs the film adaptation.
1998
Penguin Classics publishes the edition of record.
Book editions
Hardcover
- Hardcover
- The Century Co.
- 1918
Paperback
- Paperback
- Virago
- 1980
- Paperback
- Penguin Classics
- 1998
- 9780141180656
Reader reviews
Readers may also like
A Month in the Country
A veteran's damaged inner life enters an English landscape far from the trenches.
Read our take
The Good Soldier
An involved narrator must revise what respectability and marriage have taught her to see.
Read our take
The Return of the Soldier: frequently asked questions
What has Chris forgotten?
He has lost roughly fifteen years and believes it is 1901. He does not remember his marriage, his son, or the First World War.
Why does Chris remember Margaret?
She belongs to the last period his mind accepts. Their youthful relationship at Monkey Island feels present to him.
What cures Chris?
Spoiler: Margaret shows him belongings of his dead son Oliver, reconnecting the grief that links the missing years.
Is the cure a happy ending?
No. Memory returns, but so do bereavement, an unhappy marriage, and the possibility of return to war.
Who narrates the novel?
Chris's cousin Jenny narrates. Her class-conscious judgments change as she comes to understand Margaret.
Is it a novel or novella?
It is short enough to be called a novella informally, but Penguin and the Library of Congress catalogue it as a novel; this page follows those records.
If you like Rebecca West
Explore authors with a similar voice, perspective, and influence.
Martha Gellhorn
War correspondent who covered the Spanish Civil War, D-Day, and conflicts across five more decades; Hemingway's third wife, 1940–1945.
View author
Louis-Ferdinand Céline
The doctor of the Paris slums who wrote the century's blackest, funniest novel — and changed the sound of French prose.
View author
Kurt Vonnegut
American novelist whose fiction combines satire, science fiction, and the experience of surviving the bombing of Dresden.
View author
References
References
The sources below include the primary text, editions, scholarship, archival materials, and other records that informed this page. They document The Return of the Soldier, its publication, and its place in literary history.
2The Return of the Soldier — Google Books edition record
Official recordGoogle BooksUsed forGoogle Books catalogue used to cross-check edition metadata.
3The Return of the Soldier — Internet Archive ISBN catalogue
Official recordInternet ArchiveUsed forInternet Archive catalogue used to cross-check holdings.
4The Return of the Soldier — Library of Congress books catalogue
Official recordLibrary of CongressUsed forLibrary of Congress ISBN catalogue used to cross-check the modern edition.
5The Return of the Soldier
NovelProject GutenbergUsed forComplete public-domain text used for plot, ending, character, and style details.
6The Return of the Soldier, 1918 edition
Official recordLibrary of CongressUsed forDigitized 1918 edition used for first-edition metadata and book type.
7The Return of the Soldier
Official recordPenguin Random HouseUsed forOfficial publisher record used for the modern edition and critical framing.
8The Return of the Soldier
Official recordBroadview PressUsed forPublisher edition record used to cross-check class and war framing.
9The Return of the Soldier (1982)
WebsiteBritish Film InstituteUsed forBFI record used for the 1982 film.
i
Why these sources are here
The primary text is the baseline reference for every book page. Additional references document publication history, interpretation, and historical context where that evidence is available.
Explore more resources